Following from my recent post on the subject it occurs to me that, not only might it be an interesting study to find out how learning infects social groups, it is quite possible that we might use knowledge so gleaned to improve learning throughout a community. For instance, if we can identify 'promiscuous learners' (sorry, might need a less value-laden term!) then it might make sense to concentrate our educational efforts on them. Essentially, these would be people with a large number of social ties, strong ones if possible, what Malcom Gladwell calls Connectors. It is very likely that they might have other interesting shared characteristics too.
Incidentally, I think that Gladwell's ideas on how social epidemics occur are quite relevant to my developing thesis, but are also quite distinct. This is not just about the spread of ideas, memes or fashions. It is about the spread of knowledge and the growth of understanding, not just the transmission of information. Learning changes us and consequently changes those around us, but not necessarily in the same ways that we have changed. This series of posts illustrates this fairly well, albeit coarsely: the direct inspiration comes from a paper about the spread of obesity, but pulls in ideas and connections from many other things that interest me. In selecting the aspect of the paper that had personal relevance (almost certainly not the main thing the authors wanted to convey) I was infected by the learning but not (directly) the content of the paper.
This way of seeing things is helping me to make more sense of the distinctions between groups, networks and collectives that Terry Anderson and I have been writing about lately.
Networks
Networks are ultimately concerned with (often weak but sometimes strong) one-to-one connections between the individual nodes of the system and it is at this level that transmission of infection may be most likely to occur. I suspect that this is also where mutation may be most likely to happen: the stronger the mutual link, the more likely it is that shared interests and common goals will lead to more harmonised learning. Weaker and more occasional ties increase the diversity and range of knowledge within the greater system.
Links may often be much stronger in one direction than another but still cause infection. For example, I very much doubt that Howard Rheingold sees me as part of his network but, through subscribing to Smart Mobs, I see him as, at least in a sense, a part of mine. This asymmetry again opens up the system to greater mutation, and seems increasingly common as our networks extend through social software. A well-connected node may communicate with many other nodes, but seldom with the intention of singling out a particular set of identified individuals. Indeed, the node may have no awareness at all of those who see him or her as part of their networks.
Groups
In contrast, communication in groups may sometimes be between individuals but it more typically follows a one-to-specified-many pattern. The spread of infection is therefore quite different and, significantly, quite contained within the group. Just as stronger one-to-one links in networks probably lead to greater alignment, there is likely to be greater homogeneity of the infection in a group. Groups may be seen as hothouses for cultivating specific kinds of learning (although this does not necessarily mean that the final form of that learning will be clear in advance).
It is not unusual for large groups to be composed of sub-groups, many of which overlap, leading to hybrid network-group entities. Equally, it is certain that almost all members of a given group will be networked with others, so networks again take infection out of the group and into the wild. It would be interesting to study groups with few or no network ties (perhaps some monasteries or isolated villages, for instance) to see what happens. I would hypothesise that, without the infectious agency of networking, they might run out of learning steam or, at the very least, lead to more homogenous and aligned learning than those with more connections.
Collectives
Collectives are different again, and may have no equivalent in natural outbreaks of disease. Transmission in a collective occurs from the group to the individual, the group entity arising as a result of individual interactions, so any infection comes from the many, not the one. Where it gets interesting is in the implied recursion: the collective infects the individual, so the collective is composed of many infected individuals, which as a collective again reinfect themselves and so on ad infinitum. If we look at a massive collective system like Google, Amazon or Wikipedia, this gets really interesting: we might see them as causing a worldwide plague of learning, a positive recursive feedback loop not unlike that suggested in Gordon Pask's conversation theory, but where one of the actors is the system itself.
Collectives can co-exist peacefully with other forms and even arise from them. For instance, networks are often interesting when we look at the large-scale patterns within them. When we use a computer system to identify those patterns, it can (in principle) feed them back to the individuals who make up the network: i.e. the network becomes a collective, a cyborg composed of algorithms, connections and people. To an extent, anonymised voting within a group might serve a collective function. In effect, collectives increase the number of entities communicating within a system and, in so doing, increase the opportunities for infection and potential mutations along the way.
My ideas are still a bit fuzzy here, but I'm enjoying this intellectual excursion into the land of metaphor. Hope you do too.
Original: https://community.brighton.ac.uk/pg/blog/jd29/read/80772/another-ramble-on-infectious-learning
By: Jon Dron
Posted: July 27, 2007, 10:37 am
The Landing is a social site for Athabasca University staff, students and invited guests. It is a space where they can share, communicate and connect with anyone or everyone.
Unless you are logged in, you will only be able to see the fraction of posts on the site that have been made public. Right now you are not logged in.
If you have an Athabasca University login ID, use your standard username and password to access this site.
We welcome comments on public posts from members of the public. Please note, however, that all comments made on public posts must be moderated by their owners before they become visible on the site. The owner of the post (and no one else) has to do that.
If you want the full range of features and you have a login ID, log in using the links at the top of the page or at https://landing.athabascau.ca/login (logins are secure and encrypted)
Posts made here are the responsibility of their owners and may not reflect the views of Athabasca University.
Comments
nd he departs the club alongside Head of Fitness Alfredo Vergori and Matteo Festa.
conor mcgregor shirts funny http://www.wordinsong247.com/D-conor-mcgregor-shirts-funny
- conor mcgregor shirts funny
Terry 4 EPL trophy on his name and Gerrard(slippy-G) 0 pic.
asics gel 2 http://www.websasics.com/W-asics-gel-2.html
- asics gel 2
“We have some very important games in front of us.
saucony baby ride http://www.storesauconys.com/D-saucony-baby-ride
- saucony baby ride
The fans came out in numbers and never stopped singing.
nike air max 90 essential white http://www.funshops.nl/Goedkope-Nike-Air-Max-90-PRM-Tape-Schoenen-Licht-Geel-(Nike-Air-Max-90-Essential-White)-T3190.html
- nike air max 90 essential white
5million alleged scam to rip off sports fans by selling tickets at up to four-times their face-value.
Barbour Scrambler Men Quilted Jackett Black http://www.leclothing.com/Barbour-Scrambler-Men-Quilted-Jackett-Black-AA2479.html
- Barbour Scrambler Men Quilted Jackett Black
" players he wants at Stamford BridgeDiego a No-GoDiego Costa ready to fight for his place under Antonio Conte at Chelsea despite Atletico Madrid interestconte's cruiseChelsea pre-season fixtures: Where you can watch The Blues this summerPell's BellsChelsea, Everton and Stoke target Graziano Pelle offered deal to quit Southampton for China switchGo higher, AntValencia reject Chelsea's £40m bid for Andre Gomes as they hold out for a whopping £55m But the Italian, whose side will travel to Austria and the US for pre-season, was told in no uncertain terms that Lollichon, mentor to former Blues ‘keeper Petr Cech, would be going nowhere and no more new backroom staff would be allowed."
nike bambino scarpe http://www.netl.it/Nike-Jr--Mercurial-Vortex-II-FG-Bambini-Brillante-Argento-Mango-Hyper-Turchese-Metallic-Scarpe-Nike-Bambino-Scarpe-PZ1223.html
- nike bambino scarpe
"The Villans have just once all season in all competitions, while have lost three and drawn SEVEN games in the second tier."
asics gel lyte 3 pas cher http://www.kokin.fr/asics-gel-lyte-3-femme-noir-Asics-Gel-Lyte-3-Pas-Cher-TT2710.html
- asics gel lyte 3 pas cher
I was going to leave it but he had a joke about it.
innovative design http://www.leclothing.com/Moncler-Serre-Ruffle-Hoodie-Down-Coat-Beige-Moncler-Canada-B29d2548--innovative-design-AA7562.html
- innovative design
Northern Irishman McNair will bring slightly more top-flight experience to the Sunderland squad.
Michael Kors Big Logo Large Brown Satchel (Cheap Michael Kors Wallets) http://www.bangkokohomassage.com/Michael-Kors-Big-Logo-Large-Brown-Satchel-Cheap-Michael-Kors-Wallets-GS3758.html
- Michael Kors Big Logo Large Brown Satchel (Cheap Michael Kors Wallets)
"And on the very real possibility of some of his team-mates being shown the exit door in the coming weeks, Bitton said: Its not my decision about players."
cheap asics sneakers http://www.asicswebs.com/W-cheap-asics-sneakers.html
- cheap asics sneakers
"Its just as well for under-fire Gary Neville that Lionel Messi, Neymar and Luis Suarez will miss the Copa del Rey clash at Valencia this evening."
lebron 10 for sale http://www.nkwebs.com/D-lebron-10-for-sale
- lebron 10 for sale
Getty Images6Man City defender Gael Clichy challenges Schweinsteiger in a derby last termGetty Image.
red and blue jordan 1 http://www.jordanwebs.com/K-red-and-blue-jordan-1
- red and blue jordan 1
Klopps team also fired in 25 shots to Burnleys three but the two that were on target from the home team both found the net.
air jordans high heels comprar http://www.elcielojuguetes.es/Jordan-High-Heels-Mujer-Rebajas-zapatillas-Air-Jordan-High-Heels-Mujer-High-Heels-Real-Outlet-US-Air-Jordans-High-Heels-Comprar-ES7478.html
- air jordans high heels comprar
Staffordshire Police said six Bristol Rovers fans had “sustained minor injuries and 30 had been ejected from the ground.
asics gt 2000 2 mujer Beige http://www.zapatillasasicsgel.es/D-asics-gt-2000-2-mujer-Beige
- asics gt 2000 2 mujer Beige
"Related StoriesIron the HammersWhy are West Ham called The Hammers and The Irons, and which is the o."
adidas stan smith 2014 http://zx.venditawebs.it/Adidas-Stan-Smith-Bianche-Nere-Adidas-Stan-Smith-2014-QWER10097.html
- adidas stan smith 2014
He has good ability and pace in the wide areas and also has good experience of English football.
short ralph lauren pas cher http://www.villastbenoit.fr/polo-hommes-survetement-nouveau-lutter-contre-collier-pas-cher-occasionnel-norme-gris-rouge-Short-Ralph-Lauren-Pas-Cher-T18366.html
- short ralph lauren pas cher
"17;s agent was reportedly in Rome to finalise negotiations on ThursdayAnd it now appears that Nainggolan has indeed kept his word to Spalletti, with Italian daily Corriere dello Sport claiming a new contract agreement is on the horizon."
nike free run green mens http://www.nkshop-cheap.com/Cheap-Nike-Free-5-0-V2-Grey-Neon-Green-Nike-Free-Run-Green-Mens-T2361.html
- nike free run green mens
The Spain Under-21 stopper – known simply as Pau – was on Tottenhams radar before Hugo Lloris picked up a hamstring injury in their Premier League opener at Everton.
Cheap Nike Hyperdunks Women Black Blue White http://www.1nikeshop.com/Cheap-Nike-Hyperdunks-Women-Black-Blue-White-SH15627.html
- Cheap Nike Hyperdunks Women Black Blue White
"You could argue I was being selfish and, yes, I did want to? prolong my career with Newcastle, which I managed to do until 2006."
6pm shoes adidas http://adidas.itscarpe.it/D-6pm-shoes-adidas.html
- 6pm shoes adidas
I seem to do well in games against the local rivals and Im hoping it will be no different with England.
Columbia Titan Ice Polo T-shirts tech short sleeve Black Men's clothing http://www.leclothing.com/Columbia-Titan-Ice-Polo-T-shirts-tech-short-sleeve-Black-Men-and-apos-s-clothing-AA7403.html
- Columbia Titan Ice Polo T-shirts tech short sleeve Black Men's clothing
at Paris Saint-GermainOlivier Giroud has only played once so far this season — and there are still huge question marks over the Frenchman.
asics kanaku http://www.zapatillasasicsgel.es/D-asics-kanaku
- asics kanaku
";s Carlisle who remain the only unbeaten side in the division, comfortably thrashing sorry Morecambe 3-0."
Mammut Aconcagua Pro ML Woman Jackets Blue/Green Climbing http://www.leclothing.com/Mammut-Aconcagua-Pro-ML-Woman-Jackets-Blue-Green-Climbing-AA11384.html
- Mammut Aconcagua Pro ML Woman Jackets Blue/Green Climbing
Getty27Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang is apparently negotiating a move away from Borussia DortmundPierre-.
basket adidas superstar soldes http://www.adidassoldes.fr/Adidas-Superstar-Fleur-Basket-Adidas-Superstar-Soldes-STAR6513.html
- basket adidas superstar soldes
Kroos is not believed to be keen on a move away from the Bernabeu yet he could be tempted by the chance to work again with Guardiola.
adidas originals indoor tennis mid junior http://www.twoadweb.com/K-adidas-originals-indoor-tennis-mid-junior
- adidas originals indoor tennis mid junior
PA:Press Association5Arsene Wenger could get out the cheque book for the ex-Man United starPA:Press .
adidas zx 850 toddler http://www.superstaradidas365.com/Hot-Adidas-Originals-Zx-850-White-Grey-Womens-Shoes-Adidas-Zx-850-Toddler-T1311.html
- adidas zx 850 toddler