Hi Mark - it is good that you are sceptical about "temporary centre" claims :). Since networked learning is still somewhat new (at least in its technological iteration), research on "the pedagogical value of temporary aggregations as a substitute for centralized design" is largely incomplete. Of course, there are many jumping off points: what is the impact of learner autonomy on grades? How does self-efficacy influence participation? how does active participation in a networked course influence feelings of orientation and content coherence? "Pedagogical value" can lead us into numerous side channels. 

In our elluminate discussion today, the topic of networked learning as a replacement for centralized courses was addressed somewhat. My views on this are more radical than AU's. I think a networked course could (should) replace centralized courses. However, that is not AU's stance. AU sees the landing as a means to add a social layer that is often lacking in self-paced courses, and to extend the social presence of individuals after a course ends (groups in the landing have a longer life expectancy, in theory).

wrt your comment on temporary centres as perhaps lacking critical information skills, I see it as the opposite: when we make our assumptions and views explicit, we reveal our conceptual understanding in such a way that it can be critiqued by other learners or in a way that can solicit responses from the educator. The Private Universe (http://www.learner.org/resources/series28.html) example emphasizes the failure of centralized systems of instruction that lack opportunity for learners to reveal their conceptual structures through discourse. The corrective feedback of fellow learners or the instructor is lacking if content duplication and replication are the key learning tasks. A networked course - again, theoretically - will reveal conceptual errors as learners engage. It's the educators role to monitor conversation and respond when feedback is needed.

btw #2 - your work of pulling together lists of posts is very much an example of learning. You serve as a content/conversation curator. You create artifacts as you try to make sense of complexity...and when you share those artifacts, you  help other learners make sense as well.

Mark,

I read your post with interest, specifically your comparison of the centrality, permanence and structure inherent in scholarly discourse to the dispersed, impermanent, and ill-structured (from certain povs) nature of information within social networks. The information may seem ill-structured because we do not have the correct algorithm or adequate background (e.g. prior experience, disciplinary expertise) to interpret the information in the network (or database). I agree that the results of some searches seem to be the product of a deranged computer mind (Hal perhaps), however tagging is intended to reduce some of the randomness but it is only as good as the effort put into the creation of the tags. Even then with each participant in a network having such diverse interests and unique filters with which they interpret information it is unlikely that any search will perfectly match anyone's individual needs.

Its almost a question of an orientation toward the world - one orientation (status quo) seeks to replicate pre-existing structures, patterns and practices. The other seems alien (given that it is based not on a human approach to classifying a small number of objects according to directly observable criteria) and founded on the use of algorithms and generated from vast amounts of data.

This brings me to a novel that I read sometime ago entitled The Dispossessed (Ursula K Le Guin) in which there are two opposing views of civilization, one based on a kind of seeming anarchy (but with an internal logic of human relations albeit threatened by bureaucracy and tendency towards centralization) and the other based on traditional hierarchical power structures. I think sometimes it is in how we perceive things as much as how they are. Social networks seem anarchic disruptive but they are also an organizing force. It may just be that our technology is not perfectly able to reflect the complexity (but a complexity that is penetrable) of social networks, hence the disconnect between what we expect and what we get as a result of searches.

Thanks all for your comments here.

@Michael: Let me break it down like this.

1. The preference of networked learning for temporary not fixed centres cultivates the critical skill of selection -- but at the expense of its counterpart skill, organization.

2. Both selection and organization are valuable critical skills to teach, in balance.

3. A preference for temporary centres nromalizes an individualized experience of precarity that reproduces the neoliberal ideology of privatization (structurally, not necessarily intentionally).

@George: I don't mean to suggest that "temporary centres [...] perhaps lack critical information skills," only that more fixed centres and centralizing strategies cultivate different but equally important kinds of critical skills.

Your point about the metacognitive value of "mak[ing] our assumptions and views explicit" is well taken and worth keeping front and centre for this course and for DE pedagogy in general.

@Sandra: One point I tried to make in my post is that I think networked, temporary centres are now more the "status quo" than are centralized structures. Maybe not for university curriculum, but moreso for its increasingly contingent labour force and dispersed student body. And that kind of labour and social dispersal seems to me consistent with the status quo of social relations under neoliberal globalization: flexible and mobile, but precarious and intensely surveilled.

And now I have to revisit LeGuin's novel, which I started some years ago but for now-forgotten reasons didn't finish.

I am interested in podcasts, too. I would like to make an mp3 of any long stretch of text in a course available for on-the-go listening. I liked the robotic voice of IRRODL at first, but about halfway through an article, I started to zone out and wish I could listen to a person. There really is no substitute for a good human reading voice.

In reply to: Mary Pringle

Mary,

There are several options if you want to record your own podcasts, depending on your operating system.

Macs come with GarageBand included, and PC users can download Audacity for free (little cumbersome though).

Wow! Great to find a post knkincog my socks off!
- Ethanael

I don't know if I'd have anything useful to say about your paper on science fiction and social media, but it sounds really interesting. 

Like Mary, the comment about the intersection of science fiction and social media intrigued me.  I know that there is a great deal of fan fiction surrounding seminal television science fiction such as the original Star Trek series. Is this an aspect of the synergy you mention? Or are you referring to the ARG surrounding newer series such as Lost and the fact that some fans were more engaged with the ARG than the TV series. ARG site: http://www.lostargs.com/. Specifically the blog on unsolved clues: http://www.lostargs.com/2009/09/damon-carlton-and-polar-bear-clues.html.

In reply to: Sandra Law

There is an entire community dedicated to producing fan films based on the Star Wars series. There are competitions for the best Fan Films in various categories. My favourites in this genre are Pink Five and Pink Five Strikes Back.

http://www.atom.com/funny_videos/pink5/

In the case of the Star Wars fan films the original creator (George Lucas) seems to officially support the fans' efforts.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Official_Star_Wars_Fan_Film_Awards

If you want to search nice dog, better to find web-links where you could do it. The best way to buy a puppy is to search photographs of puppy in the internet. Cheap puppies for commercial possible to search at internet. Many people all over the world use internet serve and buy dogs [url=https://2puppies.com/]craigslist seattle pets for sale[/url] here.

At 2puppies.com you should find reasonable puppies for commercial. Purchase a dog in internet – it is don’t hard way. You could search photographs of puppies and combine with a seller. You can search your dog in USA less than $200. It is as well probable to find a puppy with different color. If you want to make order and to find breed of a dog, you should use administration maintain. Professionals should find a cool for you and you would be very luck.

Little dogs for trading also are represented at online page. There are a lot of modes to buy big dog. You can find Affenpinscher or Akita. If you wish to search and to buy puppy, you should as well use service at virtual page. Administrators of the firm are added many data. If you haven’t ideas where to search services to sell dogs, you may ask specialists. Managers will suggest you.

If you want to have a big dog, you can connect with chief and they suggest you. It is very easy method to search large puppy. You should to make out that you must be very tender with your animal. Today you have a lot of chances to complete your home. At site you should also search a lot of stories about pets. At page you should also find data how better to search cheap puppies. There are many needful and interesting stories. You can also search list of animals.

If you don’t know how to feed animals, you can search varied articles about it. It is probable to find information about different kind of food for puppies. You should also search data about how better to study pets. If you don’t know needful facts about animals, you can search it at link.

However necessary to say that administration of the organization will suggest you. If you have some questions, you have chance to combine with managers and ask them about help.
- Nelsane

На tamada69.com вы имеете шанс познакомиться с разными акциями и оптимальными предложениями. На портале [url=https://tamada69.com/ceny/]недорогая свадьба в твери[/url] доступен блок, где находятся цены. Вы сможете ознакомиться и с откликами клиентов и увидеть фотографии. Чтобы воспользоваться услугами, вам нужно связаться с консультантами. Они имеют шанс проинформировать вас по интересующим вас вопросам. Вы можете обговорить на берегу касаемо тамады.

Если у вас есть цель, вы имеете шанс также обсудить все конкурсы.

При желании, специалисты имеют шанс помочь подобрать вам место проведение свадьбы или юбилея. Если вы хотите, чтобы ваша свадьба запомнилась надолго, лучше обратиться к профессионалам . Специалисты имеют шанс заинтересовать как парней и девушек, так и дедушек и бабушек на вашем мероприятии. Важно, чтобы после свадьбы у всех было поднятое настроение.

В это время многие отдают интерес тамадам, которые не используют в своей работе пошлости, грубости. Все администраторы организации находятся мастерами своего дела, которые устроены не пятый день. Вы сможете зарезервировать ведущего за несколько дней и обговорить персонально с ним все вопросы.

Если на празднике будет небольшое количество танцев, специалисты могут придумать состязания с танцами. Временами бывает так, что посетители хотят, чтобы на празднике были конкурсы, посвященные их профессии. Организовать это с содействием ведущих также реально.

Заказать услуги ведущих возможно на интересующее вас время на сайте - [url=https://tamada69.com/]тамада тверь тверь[/url] , вы имеете шанс организовать хохотное и комичное настроение людей на весь вечер или всю ночь. Квалифицированные специалисты смогут провести свадьбу так, что вы обратитесь к услугам специалистов еще раз.

Проведение пира реально также в любое время месяца. Вне зависимости от того, где вы решите провести свадьбу, ведущая мог бы подстроиться. Если вы стремитесь воспользоваться услугами ведущего за городом, обсудить это также реально заранее. По основным моментам вы имеете шанс обращаться к менеджерам компании.

Сотрудники имеют шанс проконсультировать вас и ответят на все ваши вопросы.
- Lerniktuh

[b]Самая лучшая студия дизайна в Питере[/b]

С увеличением благосостояния российского народа, все большее число обитателей Питера начинает задумываться о том, как обеспечить максимальный уровень комфорта в своем доме или за рабочим столом.

Студия designgroup-spb.ru уже много лет работает на внутреннем рынке дизайна интерьеров и предлагает жителям Северной столицы собственные услуги. Примеры дизайнерских проектов указанной фирмы вы сможете отыскать на официальном сайте фирмы, что был назван выше, а также на аккаунтах компании в крупных социальных сетях.

Работа с всяким заказчиком тут начинается с долгой беседы, когда обсуждаются все желания заказчика, в течение такого маленького собеседования дизайнер может сделать множество набросков. Затем работник DesignGroup начинает трудиться над подготовкой парочки макетов дизайна, из которых потом вы выбираете идеальный вариант.

Затем этого начинается процесс составления полноценного технического задания, который может длиться несколько недель.

После согласования технического задания и согласования договора организация подготовит для вас нормальный трехмерный проект дизайна интерьера для указанного помещения. После всех корректировок полученная визуализация послужит окончательным проектом дизайна, на который будут ориентироваться строительные бригады в течении ремонта.

При необходимости сотрудники дизайн-студии могут забрать на себя заботы по выбору подходящих строительных материалов, а также проконтролируют работу строителей, дабы они не отклонились от документации.

Такая услуга как [url=http://designgroup-spb.ru/]дизайн квартиры спб[/url] сегодня пользуется все большим спросом со стороны жителей РФ. Если вы хотите жить в красивом помещении, разнообразные участки которого гармонируют друг с другом, то вам следует поручить работу по прорисовке дизайн-проекта специалистам.

Наша компания присутствует на рынке более десяти лет, за время работы нашими партнёрами стали сотни физических лиц и десятки больших фирм Санкт-Петербурга, некоторые наиболее запоминающиеся из наших проектов доступны на страничке фирмы в Вконтакте.

Главным преимуществом данной студии перед массой конкурентов стало самое внимательное отношение к пожеланиям клиентам, даже если они время от времени противоречат изначальной концепции интерьера, любой элемент интерьера будет внесён в 3D модель лишь после детального обсуждения со специалистом.
- Carikatrads