Landing : Athabascau University

Activity

  • Jon Dron commented on a bookmark » Assessing teachers’ digital competencies Virtual Canuck April 29, 2015 - 11:23am
    I don't know about grand design principles: I suspect they only occur more often in bigger projects because of quantity, rather than quality, though there is probably also a benefit to be had from having a team discussing and trying things - more...
  • Well-written and intelligently argued paper from Richard W. Patterson, using an experimental (well, nearly) approach to discover the effects of a commitment device, reminder and focus tool to improve course completion and performance in a MOOC....
  • Thomas Frey provides an analysis of current trends in education (and, more broadly, learning) and predicts a grim future for colleges and, by extension, schools and universities. This is not a uniformly well-informed article - Frey is clearly an...
  • Terry Anderson on an Estonian approach to assessing teacher competences (and other projects) using Elgg - the same framework that underpins the Landing. I've downloaded the tool they have developed, Digimina, and will be trying it out, not just for...
    Comments
    • Terry Anderson April 28, 2015 - 11:27pm

      I look forward to seeing and hearing how this elgg application works Jon.

      Indeed the idea of hypothesis generation as the final phase of a design based research project is the "sceiency" way to think and talk about research. But it is to get away from that thinking that makes me prefer words from design sphere. One deosn't formally test a hypothesis when designing a building or a table, one normally just builds it, based upon implicit and explicit design principles from past, plus any emergent innovations. If successful, based upon esthetics and user adoption, then the innovation moves slowly towrds being an established 'design principle".  Not just a confirmed hypothosis.

      Really the two aren't that dissimilliar, but I like the design orientation. 

      Finally, indeed a scaled down DBR research project (as done for a thesis or final project) rarely leads to the format or adoption of grand design principles, but as you suggest smaller iterations that create enough success to justify the intervention and enough ideas for an iterative round of doing it again.

       

    • Jon Dron April 29, 2015 - 11:23am

      I don't know about grand design principles: I suspect they only occur more often in bigger projects because of quantity, rather than quality, though there is probably also a benefit to be had from having a team discussing and trying things - more opportunities for discovery and serendipity as a result of diverse views. Those smaller iterations are often where the biggest innovations emerge though - the 'aha!' moments come at least as often from tinkering and realising that things could be different as from reflective review. In fact, it is often a result of mistakes or surprise side-effects (exaptations) so it's a dialogue with the tools. And that's why I like 'hypothesis' ...

      The table you are building is not a test of the hypothesis: it is the hypothesis. The test of it occurs in the iteration (the third stage); as you use it, then go back to the previous stage and think about what you have done, what effect it had, whether there were any issues, surprises or adjacent possibles, then maybe modify it or start to make a new one. The implementation of the idea (the hypothesis) is not the same thing as the idea - it's something else, in which the materials, ways it is used, constraints, path-dependencies and side-effects play an important role too. I rather like that - it's a science of the concrete that puts proper emphasis on the created object as opposed to just the ideas that inform it. The things we create are not a product of the thinking process but part of it, with an interdependent and important role to play. It's a way of recognizing the distributed nature of cognition, how the objects and processes we create contribute meaningfully as an active part our thoughts and beliefs.

      The plugin installs OK, but it relies on some IMS QTI files that I don't have access to yet, though it looks like it should be possible to import questions etc from any QTI package - no time to check at the moment, but I will do so when things get less busy. It's not a brilliantly written plugin for general purpose use as it mixes in a whole load of theming and embodied assumptions that it will be used to create a stand-alone dedicated site: not quite the Elgg way of doing things. But I think it might be the basis of something more useful.

  • Report on a nice bit of cognitivist research - as the title suggests, delayed feedback (ie don't give the answer right away) assists retention, and is best done after an unpredictable delay of a few seconds. What's most interesting about it is the...
  • Jon Dron commented on a bookmark Policy on Adoption of Open Source Software for Government of India in the group Open Source Software April 25, 2015 - 12:08pm
    India seems to be going further than most in mandating open source rather than simply preferring it. Others are heading in that direction too, though. I was heartened to discover that the government in my homeland has specified both a preference for...
  • This is pretty bad news for universities in Russia, coming on top of existing major cuts. It is notable that this mostly affects certificate mills with dubious credentials and very shady practices that have sprung up since the 90s, but will also...
  • Quite a slide in just five years! It is blamed by the incoming VC on general drops in student numbers in the UK, that most notably affect part-time students (like AU, all of the OU's students are part-time). A recent article suggested a 37% drop in...
  • This is an obvious development and one that we will see a great deal more of in the coming months and years. The real 'innovation' (though many of us have been arguing for this for a long time and ASU is not the first - it's just a big one with a...
  • Jon Dron uploaded the file Boundaries in Social Spaces April 13, 2015 - 8:49pm
    Slides from my presentation a couple of days ago at Social Media 2015 in Hong Kong. The general idea behind this is an extension and generalization of the ideas Terry Anderson and I have discussed surrounding context and its importance in virtual...
  • Jon Dron created a wiki page Open source course in the group Open Source Software April 4, 2015 - 2:59pm
    This page is meant to open up (in the spirit of open source) the development of an open course on open source. Tip For alternative editing methods use Pandoc to convert from HTML into your favorite markup language (Markdown or...
    Comments
  • Thanks Mark!  And thanks Shafiq - I missed replying to this. Indeed, grades all too easily turn into currency. I don't think that's going to go away and I'm not sure that it should, though it is more than a little bizarre that you might judge...
  • Jon Dron bookmarked Given Enough Money, All Bugs Are Shallow in the group Open Source Software April 4, 2015 - 11:30am
    Jeff Atwood (StackExchange, Discourse) in typically brilliant form on the problem with the 'enough eyes' theory. He makes a strong point, citing the Heartbleed vulnerability, that the vast majority of open source developers do not actually review...
    Comments
    • Viorel Tabara April 7, 2015 - 9:05pm

      Some food for thought:

      • Yes, given enough money all bugs are shallow: use Coverity:
      Tom Lane pushed:

      - Fix multiple bugs and infelicities in pg_rewind.  Bugs all spotted
        by Coverity, including wrong realloc() size request and memory
        leaks.  Cosmetic improvements by me.  The usage of the global
        variable "filemap" here is still pretty awful, but at least I got
        rid of the gratuitous aliasing in several routines (which was
        helping to annoy Coverity, as well as being a bug risk).
        http://git.postgresql.org/pg/commitdiff/c67f366fa9f748257861ee233b47b80eb5ffa857
      • Yes, given enough eyeballs are bugs are shallow: Trusting Tor

       

       

  • Jon Dron bookmarked AU Landing Project on GitHub in the group Open Source Software April 2, 2015 - 9:50am
    Some of the Elgg plugins we at AU have created or adapted for the Landing. Not always up to date, not all stable versions, not complete, but includes a lot of the main ones we have worked on.
  • Yes, you are right Hongxin - education is about more than learning! At least, our educational systems are about a lot more than what they intentionally teach. Accreditation and child-minding are obvious functions, but it is also about sustaining and...
  • It probably comes as no surprise that I have an extremely low opinion of PISA, the well-intentioned but operationally horrific international testing framework used to compare schooling (I use the word advisedly) in different countries. PISA matters...
  • Indeed - a good overview of the issues, thanks Shawn. Like all technologies, it ain't what you do, it's the way that you do it, and context makes a huge difference. It is not possible to generalize too conclusively because, for any given design (of...
  • Jon Dron bookmarked RIP community@brighton March 23, 2015 - 8:45pm
    Community@brighton was once the biggest social media site within an educational institution in the world, with tens of thousands of users and a very active participatory community in its first two or three years. Sadly, though it continued for a...
  • Well this is nice - I (only just) made the top 20! Nice to be counted among the notably more luminous folk even if my feeble contributions are orders of magnitude smaller. Of course, this is just about people who write about educational technology...
    Comments
  • Beyond the group: how education is changing and why institutions need to catch up
    An exploration of why and how universities are changing whether we like it or not, and what we might do about that.
    Comments
    • Hongxin Yan April 1, 2015 - 12:11pm

      Excellent points, Jon. We need to take the advantage of Internet for education. Now every learner has the equipments and channels to connect with a bigger world, or even the whole world than before, not just their classmates and teachers. Learning can happen not only in a closed system, but also in an open environment, as you said "We are swimming in a sea of billions of teachers". This is what Internet brings to us, and we need to embrace the opportunity. Landing is the start.

      In reality, I think education is not just learning though. That's why it would take time for changing.

       

    • Jon Dron April 1, 2015 - 1:25pm

      Yes, you are right Hongxin - education is about more than learning! At least, our educational systems are about a lot more than what they intentionally teach. Accreditation and child-minding are obvious functions, but it is also about sustaining and (hopefully) creating culture. Educational systems are means of both establishing and replicating the shared knowledge and norms of a society, and that is a really important role. That role has for centuries been more and more distributed across other technologies (like town criers, books, newspapers, radio, TV etc), but the Internet is accelerating the rate of change, and massively altering its dynamic. We need to be highly critical of those changes and do our best to steer them in a direction that does not lead to mob rule, divisive factions, the loss of privacy, the valorization of narcissism, the shallowing of attention, and all those other things the doom-prophets rightly fear but, like it or not, the change is happening. 

      Education (big 'E') is a huge complex adaptive system. Like most such systems, it has a will to survive, and has established its role in a larger ecosystem in ways that would make its immediate removal unthinkable and catastrophic, quite apart from the effects it would have on those within it.  Bearing that in mind, those of us in an educational system seldom ask whether it is needed at all - we instead ask how to improve it. The same goes of all its subsystems. We tend to ask not whether courses or classrooms or exams are necessary, but how we should make them better. That's good, up to a point - we do need to improve - but it's a bit like improving audio cassette tapes when everyone else has moved to Blu-Ray and digital streaming. Eventually, no matter how deeply entwined a system may be with the broader ecosystem, something has to give. I think we need to be ready. And, yes, the Landing is a start!

    • Anonymous June 10, 2018 - 7:09pm

      I really codn'lut ask for more from this article.
      - Lucy